I have taken to making iron skillet pies, recently, much to the delight of our family. I even bought a 10.25 inch cast iron skillet to do this, though truthfully we were lacking in that particular skillet size in the kitchen.
Eddie adores cast iron skillets and was more than pleased that we acquired a new piece! However, I just noticed now that I grabbed the larger size skillet for the pie I made last night (below). No wonder it was so heavy to get in and out of Agatha! Still learning to remember we have the slightly smaller size, now.
Below, homemade peach-blueberry iron skillet pie with my famous pie crust recipe.
For cast iron skillet pies, make my pie crust recipe below and your filling according to it's particular fruit recipe (usually a combination of lemon juice, flour, spices, salt and sugar for cooked berry pies).
Before you assemble, however, melt a little butter and brown sugar together in the bottom of your cast iron skillet until melted and bubbling. Remove from heat and working carefully, place your bottom crust atop the butter/sugar mixture, add your filling, then cover with your top crust (crust recipe below). Sprinkle some granulated sugar on top, make sure there are cuts in the top crust, maybe some small pieces of butter under the top crust, and then cover with tin foil and bake for 20 minutes in a hot oven. After 20 minutes, remove foil and cook for another 20 minutes more until golden brown. Remove from heat carefully and cool, or, serve pie warm with ice cream!
I don't make pretty pie crusts, but they are DELICIOUS pie crusts. The secret is a butter/Crisco mix and orange juice for the liquid. This is one area where I could be a perfectionist about chilling the crust and rolling it out precisely and all that, but I gave up on that a long time ago. I prefer to go the rustic route, instead.
It's because of this pie crust that I have always been a pie snob. I rarely eat pie in restaurants because usually, the pie crust can't compare to mine.
I'm serious, follow the ingredient recipe below exactly and you'll see what I mean. (And ALWAYS used real butter, never margarine or butter substitute.)
M's Famous Pie Crust
2.5 cups all-purpose flour
1 cube COLD unsalted butter (1/2 cup)
1/2 cup Crisco all-vegetable shortening
generous pinch of salt
4 tbsp orange juice
Place everything except the orange juice in a large mixing bowl.
To do this recipe right, you will need to do it the old fashioned way and use a pastry hand blender. It looks like a hand-held metal half moon with about four blades for the moon part, like this:
Cut the butter and shortening into small pieces into the flour/salt mixture until everything is incorporated and the shortening is evenly mixed in and fine pebbles.
Add the orange juice, then mix well with your hands until you have a dough. It may be sticky, depending on how warm the day and your kitchen. Use a tad more flour if you need to until its not.
Shape into a ball and place covered into the fridge until firmed up, if you want, for easier rolling out.
OR
Cut ball in half and roll each half out until about 1 mm thick between two pieces of parchment paper using a rolling pin. Place one half of the flattened dough in the bottom of a standard sized pie pan and do the same with the second half of dough, for the top crust. Try to cut a pretty shape in the middle center of the top crust for decoration and to help the filling as it cooks.
You may need to piece smaller pieces of dough together in the bottom of the pie pan before you can crimp the edges around the pan to evenly cover the bottom of the pie pan.
Below, servings of warm peach blueberry pie with French vanilla Tillamook ice cream. I dubbed this particular flavor of pie "sex in a bowl" when served warm with vanilla ice cream way back in 1997.